Do you want the Road Tax system to change? Do you have thoughts on the potential changes to the Road Tax system? | No thanks

I have a 1995 Volkswagen Golf that needs £1000 of repair work - should I keep or scrap it?

I have a 1995 Golf GTI 16V, which I've owned from new. It has failed its MoT due to under body corrosion. The estimated repair is likely to be around £1000, although the garage say this will depend on the extent of the corrosion. They say that they'll only know how bad it is when all the covers are removed. I think there is also a drain on the battery, which is undiagnosed. The current MoT expires in mid-April. The car has done 106,000 miles, but I'm a senior and do very little now.

Asked on 20 March 2018 by mike sheldrick

Answered by Keith Moody
Golf are always desirable cars, especially in GTi form. Over the past decade, we've seen a domino effect. For example, when prices for a Mk1 GTi got too high, people started going after the Mk2 GTi. Prices for these are now high, but we're not necessarily seeing a shift towards the Mk3 GTi. Perhaps because in the 1990s, the GTi wasn't actually the quickest car in the range - that honour went to the VR6. Only you can decide if it's worth spending the money to keep the car going - do you like driving it? Does it mean a lot to you? To give you a rough idea of Mk3 GTi values, projects tend to be about £400 while the very best seem to go for about £2000-£2500.
Similar questions
I was wondering if you had any ideas to help with my dad's car. He owns a Morris Minor Traveller that has not been used for about 25 years. It is parked on the drive but has been gradually rotting away...
I have a 2001 Mazda MX5 1.8 with around 70,000 miles on the clock. It will probably fail its next MoT. Even though the engine and gearbox are still top notch, the cost of essential repairs (including exhaust/cat...
My beloved 20 year old Jaguar XJ6 has developed electrical problems, due partly to water getting into the wiring. My mechanic has sourced some used parts (Jaguar don't make them any more), but the immobiliser...
Related models
Excellent performance from 16V, all models have a good performance/economy balance, drives brilliantly out of town, great build quality, longevity and reliability

Ask Honest John Right column