Should I buy a cheap runaround or nearly-new, and how should I store it in winter?

When I retire next year, I need to buy a car. I can't decide whether to spend £1000-£5000 on an old banger which, while cheap to buy, will no doubt cost a bit to run, or £10,000-£20,000 on something which will cost less to run and will (in theory) last longer. As I will be on a pension I want to conserve my cash. And I need something that will be happy sleeping in a garage every UK winter while my wife and I are residing abroad. Any thoughts?

Asked on 25 May 2013 by DM, via email

Answered by Honest John
Even hooked up to a battery conditioning trickle charger in a well-ventilated garage, a car will inevitably deteriorate if left for long periods of time. The poorer the state of the fluids, the higher the rate of deterioration, so it should be fully serviced before being locked away. Basically you buy new to get a long warranty and, if you re-sell within four or five years, in exchange for heavy depreciation you may not have to spend anything on repairs and replacements. After five years old, the bill for repairs and replacements will gradually grow to the same as the depreciation, and will then increasingly exceed the depreciation. The only way to protect your investment is to buy an appreciating 'classic' in exceptional condition. But the problem with that is the classics that appreciate the most are the least practical to use. However, think along the lines of a perfect MGB, any you might come out smiling.
Similar questions
I would like to sell my 1976 Triumph Spitfire 1500 with soft and hard top. It is in reasonable condition and has a new radiator, new carbs and new clutch, six months' tax and nearly a year’s MoT. Please...
I live overseas but return to the UK for a few months each summer. For the last few years I have investigated purchasing a classic car with the idea of putting the car into storage whilst I'm away. Frustratingly...
I am the owner and registered keeper of various old vehicles in storage: two old Lancias in lock-ups, one being 1973 and free of VED, a 1936 Ariel Red Hunter motorbike in bits in my office basement and...
Related models
Good to look at, fun to drive, amazing parts availability, the archetypal classic roadster and coupe