Selling your classic car? It's FREE to list your car on Honest John Classics | No thanks

Why couldn't Halfords help with the battery on my 1959 Austin Healey?

As the cranking speed of my 1959 Austin Healey's starter was getting very low, I drove round to Halfords and asked them to test the battery. Their meter said ‘battery unserviceable', so I shelled out £75 for a new one. This made no difference, so I replaced the starter motor with a spare I had in the garage. Starting was now instant. Meanwhile (while I was restoring the spare starter motor), the old battery sat uncharged in the garage for a month, and never dropped below 12.56v. I took it back to Halfords and asked them to test it again. It still came up ‘unserviceable', which was not true because the problem was the starter motor. The staff declined to offer any compensation.

I asked them what the meter was actually testing, but they had no idea. One of them said it tested each cell, which it could not do as the cells are connected in series. So I put the old battery back in the car and checked the voltage drop on cranking. It dropped to 10.6v, when an acceptable figure would be 9.6v. Obviously it was in rude health. So I emailed Halfords' customer services with the story, including the magic words ‘Trading Standards'. Within 24 hours they had refunded the £75 and given me a £10 voucher for my trouble. The engine continues to start instantly on the old battery. As usual, the moral of the story is ‘caveat emptor'.

Asked on 25 August 2012 by LR, Salisbury

Answered by Honest John
Very, very strange. Basically, a good battery should charge to 13.5 volts. Your old battery's drop to 12.56 volts meant it was okay. So either the testing kit at Halfords was up the creek or the boys there did not know how to use it. You called their bluff. And you won. These days you cannot trust anyone that you don't know very well indeed.
Similar questions
Should you put grease on battery terminals to protect from corrosion?
I have a Volkswagen Golf 2.0 TDI and will be going abroad for between 4 to 6 weeks with my car parked on my driveway. No one else will be in the home when i'm away so I won't be able to trickle charge...
My 2016 Nissan X-Trail occasionally won't start The battery shows 11.8v and the dash lights up but the car only clicks when the ignition key is turned, but it starts strongly with jump leads. Any thoughts...
Related models
More power improves the Austin-Healey 3000 considerably, roomy and fun for two, a timeless classic sports car

Compare classic car insurance quotes and buy online. A friendly service offering access to a range of policies and benefits.

Get a quote