Selling your classic car? It's FREE to list your car on Honest John Classics | No thanks

Is it more environmentally friendly to run something like a Land Rover for 30 years than buy a succession of hatchbacks?

Having owned and run a 1991 Land Rover Defender since passing my test at 17 four years ago, I was pleased to see the article a few weeks back in favour of older cars as first cars. The Landy has provided trouble-free motoring, cheap insurance and servicing, and escapes the Congestion Charge. It has also coped with practically everything that university life throws at it. In defence of it being a 'gas guzzler', I've always argued that its environmental impact over its lifetime of say 30 years has got to be less than producing, running and scrapping three small hatchbacks that may only last 10 years each? Is there any truth in this?

Asked on 2 October 2010 by JC, Bristol

Answered by Honest John
That isn't the way governments are playing it. They are legislating increasingly complex safety and emissions equipment into cars that have limited life and will ensure that most become economic basket cases before they are 10 years old. In coming years we can expect to see many more 7-10-year-olds being ‘recycled’ via the crusher.
Similar questions
My wife and I have a young and growing family. Our 2009 Audi A3 Hatchback 1.9 TDI is now creaking at the seams and we're looking for a secondhand practical vehicle. It needs to be capable of carrying up...
My sister is starting a job with a reputable energy company, and she feels that she needs to drive something economical and efficient. However, my mother wants her to drive something as safe as possible....
I will be taking my 1972 Volkswagen Type 181 to Spain. When I bought the car it did not have any seatbelts fitted. I knew I didn't have to fit them but, for a bit of safety, I had lap belts fitted in the...
Related models
The ultimate 4x4. Simply unstoppable off-road. Body panels easy to replace. Latest 2.2-litre diesel offers strong pulling power. Retains its resale value like no other utility vehicle.
 

Ask Honest John