Selling your classic car? It's FREE to list your car on Honest John Classics | No thanks

Is converting my classic from an automatic gearbox to manual one wise?

I have a 1989 Jaguar XJS automatic. I'm considering converting it to a five-speed manual using a kit purchased from a reputable company. My car is still standard and has not been modified or restored in any way. I'm wondering if the conversion will affect the long term market value.

Asked on 2 May 2018 by mharbon

Answered by Keith Moody
Converting from an auto to a manual (or vice versa) very rarely goes smoothly and often causes all kinds of unforeseen headaches (and bills). It's also expensive and unlikely to add any value to the car. If your car is unmodified and original, it will be worth more if you keep it that way. If you are serious about doing this, try and find some owners that have done it and take onboard their experiences. And make sure you drive their cars - the manual box isn't always to everyone's tastes. You don't mention why you want to do this. If it's to improve fuel economy, you'd need to cover a huge amount of miles to make the cost of the conversion worthwhile (if it all), and if you're looking for more performance, there might be simpler ways to achieve this.
Similar questions
I've inherited my father's old Lada Riva 1200. It's rusty and hasn't run for 14 years, but it was owned by him alone since new and the actual one on display at the Motor Show the year he bought it. It...
I'm looking at classic Italian autos. Currently living in Italy so I have some access. I like the Lancia Appia models from the late '50s to early '60s. I like the size, styling and room but am not very...
What would be a realistic value to expect for selling my 1971 MGB GT with chrome bumpers? A purist will want to do work on it, an enthusiast will happily drive around and tinker. Any recommendations for...
Related models
Grace, pace and space. It's getting better as the years go by. Lots of versions to choose from - six-cylinder cars are brilliant.
 

Ask Honest John Right column