Selling your classic car? It's FREE to list your car on Honest John Classics | No thanks

Should I get a Rover 75 or Jaguar S-Type?

I am looking for something automatic, V6 engine, with leather interior, and a saloon preferably. My choice is either a Rover 75 or a Jaguar S Type. Do you have an opinion on which I should go for, as well as any general tips or thoughts?

Asked on 8 February 2018 by Paul Newton

Answered by Keith Moody
It's not an easy answer as both cars are different creatures - although they're both retro-styled and fairly lazy. For our money, we'd go for the S-type - but the only way you can really answer that question is to drive both. Remember, these cars are getting on a bit now so they won't handle as well as they did fresh out the box. You might find a low-mileage Rover 75 that you prefer to a more leggy Jaguar. Of course, you could always go for a Rover 75 based MG ZT - they inspire and attract enthusiasts and have excellent club support.
Similar questions
I have a mint condition 1994 Mercedes-Benz C-Class with 98,000 miles. It looks like new and drives like new. Any idea of what it may be worth? I passed its MoT today with no faults.
I'm trying to get rid of my 20 year old Mercedes-Benz SL280 with 141,000 miles on the clock. It has over six months MoT left, but I've struggled to get a valuation due to the car's age. Where would be...
My 90 year old father has a 1997 Peugeot 406 Sri Turbo 2.0-litre Petrol, which has covered 80,000 miles and been owned by the family from new. Apart from normal servicing costs, the vehicle has been trouble...
Related models
Proper, rear drive Jaguar, at its best as 3.0 V6 Sport manual.
A fine looking car from all angles, until the 2004 facelift. Destined to become a 'classic'. 2.0 diesels proving to be good long life cars with excellent clubs and spares back-up. Up to 4 stars.
 

Ask Honest John