Dream car or Budget, which comes first? Tell us your thoughts | No thanks

BMW 3 Series convertible from the '80s; good first car, or am I mad!?

After an ebay hour spent looking at these online, I was wondering whether they would be affordable as a first car? My brother will be learning to drive soon, and these seem stylish and relatively dependable.

Plus the fairly lazy throttle, sharp brakes and the nature of the car make it seem suitable for learning about car control. I am an old car fan who has learnt some basic mechanical skills while learning in a Rover Mini, and the car would not be needed for everyday use, so reliability isn't so much of an issue. Do you think this would be a wise choice?

Alternatively, would other 80s cars of this sort be suitable, such as a Mk1 Golf Convertible, or 205 CTI? We aren't looking for a modern car so much, but would love to know whether any of these options are financially viable for a young driver.
Many thanks :)

Asked on 13 January 2013 by campaj1

Answered by Honest John
E30 3-Series convertible. Most survivors have been got at, or stolen and recovered. Very hard to find a genuine, original car and a non original will be uninsurable and may even be illegal. Mk 1 Golf convertibles are usually rotted out, and new hoods for them cost thousands. A 205CTI was an unwise convertible because very light to start with and a death trap with the top cut off.
Similar questions
I thought your readers might be interested in this info. In the last 16 years I've mainly owned and run older cars. What I've found is that you can insure a lot of cars over 16 years old on a classic car...
My 17-year-old grandson is contemplating buying a Triumph Herald. what would you advise? Wwhat are the pitfalls? What should he expect to pay for a good example
I am nearing retirement and would like a reliable and economical soft top. The Mazda MX5 just seems too popular, I like the idea of a MK1 or MK2 Volkswagen Golf, but rust scares seem to be rife. Living...
Related models
Image-defining 1980s saloon, lots of options, saloon, coupe, estate and convertible, as well as four- and six-cylinder engines, all well-engineered and good to drive
 

Ask Honest John