Selling your classic car? It's FREE to list your car on Honest John Classics | No thanks

Should I buy a Rover 75 or a Mercedes-Benz W123 estate?

I need an estate car. I play around with old cars such as Rover P4s, Triumph Spitfires and the Land Rover series. I considered that a Rover 75 (except the 1.8) would be a good fit, however the ones I have seen are expensive and with high miles. I thought about a Mercedes-Benz W123 estate (I am told to avoid the 280 and any with a sunroof, with leaks causing rust) but I know nothing about the W123s except that they appear to be a good thing. I toyed with buying a Peugeot 406 3-litre executive with 45,000 miles and in mint condition, however it's not a classic and will be heavy on fuel. Please give me your opinion.

Asked on 12 May 2011 by IF, St. Annes

Answered by Honest John
W123s are not only a lot older than Rover 75s (all at least 25 years old), any good ones are also a lot more expensive. I think you'll be better off with a pre-facelift 75 2.0CDTI Tourer.
Similar questions
There are 3 holes in the top of the rear bumper. The middle one definitely acts as a drain hole. On my car, the driver's side one is pretty much filled with black plastic but water can drain out. On the...
I am looking for a first car, around the £1000-£2000 mark. It has to be able to carry four kayaks on the roof and seat four passengers, and possibly even sleep two in the boot. Ideally I would like an...
I am considering the purchase of a 1978 Mercedes-Benz W123 model. This car has only completed a genuine 27,000 miles from new. It is offered with all of the service invoices together with all the MOTs....
Related models
Beautifully made, classy and practical, estate version useful too
A fine looking car from all angles, until the 2004 facelift. Destined to become a 'classic'. 2.0 diesels proving to be good long life cars with excellent clubs and spares back-up. Up to 4 stars.
 

Ask Honest John