Selling your classic car? It's FREE to list your car on Honest John Classics | No thanks

My car had a gearbox oil change last year and now in lower gears there is a whining noise - is this likely to be a problem?

My Rover 75 had a gearbox oil change last year. In lower gears there is a whining noise which disappears when we reach 30mph. Is this likely to be a problem?

Asked on 10 December 2018 by RICHARD CARNILL

Answered by Keith Moody
You don't mention how many miles the car has done so it's unclear whether the gearbox could be failing - although these boxes are generally strong if well looked after. Is it definitely the box? It could be a wheel bearing. If you're sure it's the box, start by checking the fluid level.

One of our readers also adds that whine may be the intermediate bearing on the longer drive shaft. 'They deteriorate fast from a slight whine at low speed completely masked as speed builds up and then throw off as the bearing disintegrates and creates sufficient clearance for the shaft to exit the gearbox. Fortunately mine (at around 50,000 miles and 5 years old) didn't do any further damage but of course left a lot of oil on the road and was an expensive tow in job to repair.'
Similar questions
I can't locate the oil filling plug on the automatic gearbox of my BMW 523i E39. It looks different to that shown in the Haynes Manual and Youtube videos. The only plugs on the back of the gearbox and...
I have a 2010 Volkswagen Passat CC automatic diesel. It's started to judder when I start it. Any ideas what it could be? It's driving me mad.
I've been told by my local Skoda dealer that my 2012 Octavia 1.8 TSi DSG Estate needs a new DSG as it suffered a failure. They found metal debris in the gearbox when they stripped it. Any ideas why it...
Related models
A fine looking car from all angles, until the 2004 facelift. Destined to become a 'classic'. 2.0 diesels proving to be good long life cars with excellent clubs and spares back-up. Up to 4 stars.
 

Ask Honest John