Audi A5 or Mercedes-Benz C-Class Coupe?

First of all would like to thank you and your website for its considerable useful info and I am an avid follower of the website and find it very informative especially the Ask Honest John section. Thank You!

I'm looking at purchasing a new car and fancy the A5 1.8 manual TFSI ? Would you recommend this as a shrewd purchase ? How does it stand up against the Mercedes C-Class Coupe C180? Which would you buy and suggest similar price, age and mileage? And what finance option is the best?

Asked on 15 August 2015 by mzd322

Answered by Honest John
Great looking car, but the A5 1.8 isn't a shrewd purchase because the 1.8 TFSI and 2.0 TFSI up to the latest EA888 engines from 2013 could have problems of coking up their inlet valves and of excessive oil consumption from the piston oil rings not bedding in properly. Later cars with the uprated power outputs and lower emissions seem okay so far.Very little feedback on C-Class with the 1.6 turbo engine.

The difference between HP and PCP is that with a PCP you don't buy the whole car. With HP, if you have paid off more than 50% of the loan you can hand the car back and walk away. With a PCP you pay interest on the full buying price, but your monthly payments only pay off the estimated depreciation. At the end of the term you have the option of paying the balance and keeping the car, or walking away. But if you walk away from either deal you have to pay for any damage to the car. With a bank loan you don't have the walk away options. Fail to pay off any of the loan and the bank can come and take whatever asset you secured the car on and that may be your house not the car itself.
Tags: buying advice
Similar questions
I want to buy a small car that will fit three kids in the back. It has to have decent performance and lots of gadgets - climate control and parking sensors essential and a decent infotainment system desirable....
I spend eight months each year abroad, and four months in the UK. My wife and I want a vehicle that is comfortable enough to get us from the south of England to Paris (for at least 2 weeks) and around...
In your review of the SEAT Ateca you refer to possible lag with the petrol/auto combination. I've driven a manual Ateca which is good in all respects. Should I be concerned about ordering an auto. What...
Related models
Spacious boot. Solid build quality. Good to drive on the motorway. Good handling with quattro all-wheel drive.
Well built and attractively styled. Available with low emission diesel engines. Entry-level C180 petrol is surprisingly good.