Should my partner's 1 Series BMW be using so much oil?

In January this year my partner took delivery of a new 1 Series BMW convertible. She is delighted with the car but was surprised when a few weeks ago, after only 4000 miles, the low oil warning came up. After checking, the car did indeed need a litre of oil and she therefore queried this with the BMW dealership that supplied the car. To her surprise they confirmed that she should expect the car to use a litre of oil approximately every 600 miles. We were both surprised at this and therefore wrote to BMW UK for its official advice.

The response included, "However, this oil usage is not just for the running in of the vehicle, this will remain the same for the duration of the vehicles lifetime. This is because our vehicles are designed to use more oil when the engine is running. This act extends the lifetime of the engine and improves fuel economy." Having driven BMW cars for many years covering hundreds of thousands of miles I can only recall adding oil on perhaps three occasions over 20 plus years. We would be interested in your comments.

Asked on 4 September 2011 by AC, Reigate

Answered by Honest John
4000 miles a litre is tolerable, 600 miles a litre is not. If bought in four or five litre containers, a litre of oil for this engine is about £10. If BMW seriously expects customers to pay £10 every 600 miles for oil, then the cost is actually the equivalent of an extra 10 litres of petrol every 600 miles. How does that improve economy? Assuming the car does 40mpg and a gallon of fuel costs £6, that’s 15p a mile for fuel. But if you have to pay £10 every 600 miles for oil that’s an extra 1.67p a mile: an extra 11 per cent.
Similar questions
I have just bought a diesel Citroen DS3. I've had it for seven weeks and done 5500 miles. The oil warning light came on and when I took it to the garage the service manager said that it is normal for new...
You recently mentioned high oil consumption of BMW 4-cylinder petrol engines. I bought a BMW 1 Series convertible this year. A couple of months ago the oil warning light flashed on and, as I was local...
My wife read an article that automatic stop start on a modern engine can damage the engine beause of inadequate engine lubrication. I told her that when the engine is warm and been running a while, the...
Related models
A very entertaining car to drive, efficient yet powerful engines, superb infotainment.
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer