Does fitting the wrong tyres cause problems with the transmission on a BMW X3?
I have a 2006 BMW X3 with 76,000 miles on the clock bought last year secondhand from a small local dealer. A few weeks ago the car developed a 'knocking noise' when slowing down to stop and then moving off again, eg when in heavy stop/start traffic. After a series of 'red herrings' my local independent BMW specialist diagnosed a Dual Mass Flywheel and clutch problem. They found that the flywheel had broken apart. They replaced the flywheel and clutch, costing me £867.68p. Less than two weeks then elapsed before a very similar 'knocking noise' occurred in the same driving circumstances.
I visited the garage today to be told that this time it was not a flywheel/clutch problem but another part of the transmission system and they were not sure which. More worryingly, this whole transmission saga, I am being told, could be caused by the fact the car is not fitted with BMW approved Pirelli or Michelin tyres. The garage’s next step is to fit the car with Michelin-tyred wheels to see if this solves the problem. Failing that it my need expensive transmission repairs to get it into a saleable state. I would be grateful for your comments on the view that the BMW X3's transmission system is so sensitive that it will not tolerate tyres other than Pirelli or Michelin. The garage says that many X3 problems are caused by the 'wrong' tyres.
I visited the garage today to be told that this time it was not a flywheel/clutch problem but another part of the transmission system and they were not sure which. More worryingly, this whole transmission saga, I am being told, could be caused by the fact the car is not fitted with BMW approved Pirelli or Michelin tyres. The garage’s next step is to fit the car with Michelin-tyred wheels to see if this solves the problem. Failing that it my need expensive transmission repairs to get it into a saleable state. I would be grateful for your comments on the view that the BMW X3's transmission system is so sensitive that it will not tolerate tyres other than Pirelli or Michelin. The garage says that many X3 problems are caused by the 'wrong' tyres.
Asked on 23 November 2013 by BD, via email
![](http://images.honestjohn.co.uk/imagecache/file/pad/120x120/media/16477727/537450_458533677529584_1473549666_n.jpg)
It is normal for an 'automatic' AWD system to suffer stress if not fitted with the correct and equal size wheels and tyres. If there is a disparity between the size of tyres from one wheel to another, then the system will detect that as slippage and try to engage AWD, which will cause wear.
Similar questions
![](http://images.honestjohn.co.uk/imagecache/file/pad/75x75/media/16477727/537450_458533677529584_1473549666_n.jpg)
Last week the 7-speed DSG box of our March 2009 Volkswagen Touran Diesel packed up, having done 53,000 miles. As you can see from the mileage we do mostly distance driving and little in city traffic, moreover...
![](http://images.honestjohn.co.uk/imagecache/file/pad/75x75/media/16477727/537450_458533677529584_1473549666_n.jpg)
Why do you write so positively about VAG cars in your road tests? I’ve just read the Skoda Yeti test. You mention the 2.0 TDi. Quote from a Volkswagen main dealer: "it's the worst engine we've made",...
![](http://images.honestjohn.co.uk/imagecache/file/pad/75x75/media/16477727/537450_458533677529584_1473549666_n.jpg)
We have a 60 reg S-MAX with the power shift box. We bought it second hand from a large non-Ford dealer. When the car was 3 1/2 years old but with only 21,000 miles on the clock, in November last year,...
Related models
Handling is impressive for an SUV, large boot capacity and lots of rear-seat space, top engine choices deliver serious performance.