Why won't my insurance company quote me for changing my MINI One for a Citroen C1 VTR+?

I am currently in the process of changing my car as, having recently changed jobs, I will be using the train for everyday commuting. I will be changing my Mini One for a Citroen C1 VTR+ but I'm baffled by my insurer's reaction. I currently pay just over £600 for my Mini, I am 22 years old and have four years' no-claims bonus but my current insurer will not even quote me on the Citroen, which is a lower insurance group than the Mini. As I'm 10 months into my current policy year, I stand to lose nearly a year's no-claims bonus.

I cannot help but feel that someone at this company has rated the car as a "hot hatch" due to the VTR+ suffix , when the car is only one litre and runs on three cylinders. As per usual, I can't get to speak to anyone in authority, and wondered if you could shine some light on a problem which has my whole family baffled.

Asked on 14 May 2010 by jenniv

Answered by Dan Harrison
This is a strange one. I've just been onto the insurer's website to get a quote and had no problem whatsoever, so the car is certainly insurable. Give them one more call, explain what's happened and if they still can't help you, look elsewhere. Try the comparison sites and then give the insurers offering the best premiums a ring. Explain to them about the 10 months no-claims you stand to lose unfairly and they may offer to help you out to get your business. You may also find that you save a few quid by changing insurers, too.
Similar questions
My wife recently changed her car from a Land Rover Freelander, worth £2000 and insurance group 23, to a Renault Clio, worth £2000 and insurance group 9. When I changed the vehicle on our Admiral insurance...
The boyfriend of my neighbour's daughter damaged my car lightly. As all parties agreed it was minor damage, I said I'd get a quote and we'd get him to pay the repairer on the day, I had him booked in this...
My son is 23 years old and has 4 years no claim bonus wants to buy a second hand car up to max £2000 with hatch back as needs a roomy boot which are the best for insurance purposes?
Related models
Very comfortable. Fantastic refinement. Well equipped from mid-range models upwards.
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer